The attorneys of Kramer Shull Reeths LLP

A Team With A Track Record Of Advocating For Wisconsin Insurers And Public Entities

What to do when your insurer fails to settle within policy limits

On Behalf of | Nov 6, 2026 | Insurance Defense Litigation

You purchase insurance for peace of mind, trusting your provider to protect you if you face a lawsuit. So, what happens when a plaintiff offers to settle within your policy limits, but your insurer simply says no? Suddenly, a manageable claim can spiral into a trial that threatens your personal savings and assets. If you are facing an excess verdict because your insurer refused a reasonable demand, understanding your rights under Wisconsin law is your first line of defense.

The insurer’s duty to evaluate settlement demands

Insurance providers owe their insureds a duty of good faith. This obligation typically means they should properly investigate claims and evaluate settlement offers. If a claimant makes a demand within your policy limits, your insurer may have an obligation to seriously consider it. Whether the insurer should accept depends on factors such as the probability of liability, the potential size of a verdict and the risk that a judgment could exceed your coverage. Ignoring a fair offer may expose the company to a bad faith claim later.

Consequences of an excess verdict

A trial could result in a verdict that is much higher than your actual policy limit. In these cases, the injured party might attempt to collect the remaining balance directly from your personal assets. However, if your insurer acted in bad faith and rejected an earlier settlement opportunity, they could face responsibility for the entire judgment amount, including any amount above the policy limits.

Steps to take if your insurer refuses a fair settlement offer

You should stay actively involved when the claim filed against you is approaching your policy limit. You can send a formal letter asking the insurer to settle within the limit to protect your assets. Better still, consider retaining an experienced coverage attorney to review the facts of the claim, the status of any negotiations, and the company’s position on settlement and communicate with the insurer about its duty to settle an excess liability claim within you policy limit when it has an opportunity to do so.